How it works

Step 4: cited, recommended and well described

updated on 2026-11-18

For each question and each AI, Siggmund reads the answer the way your customer would. It does not just count citations: it looks at whether the AI recommends you, for whom, to the benefit of which competitor, and which sources it relies on.

In short

  • Three situations to tell apart: absent, outranked, wrongly described. They do not call for the same actions.
  • Four measures: your presence, the customer's reaction, the AI's sources, your reputation.
  • The results are consolidated by a Bayesian statistical model, AI by AI.

The three situations

Not appearing, appearing behind a competitor and appearing with false information are three different problems. Mixing them into a single score means choosing the wrong action.

Missing

Your brand isn't cited

"Which sofa bed for a small living room?" The AI recommends three retailers. Yours isn't one of them.

Outranked

A competitor is recommended

"Where can I buy a firm mattress?" The AI cites you, but third, and recommends a competitor first.

Poorly described

Your offer is misdescribed

"Does this retailer deliver to Belgium?" The AI says no. Your delivery page says otherwise.

Twelve questions, six AIs, one answer per cell

72answers read in this sample
45cite you
15recommend you first
7contain an error about you
Question
ChatGPT
Gemini
Perplexity
Copilot
AI Overviews
AI Mode
« A sofa bed to sleep on every night: which one should I choose? »Ahead of you : Maison Kerlan
ChatGPTCited 2nd
GeminiMissing
PerplexityCited 3rd
CopilotMissing
AI Overviews1st
AI ModeCited 2nd
« What are the best firm mattresses under €800? »Ahead of you : Duval Literie
ChatGPTMissing
GeminiMissing
PerplexityCited 4th
CopilotMissing
AI OverviewsMissing
AI ModeCited 3rd
« Which furniture store delivers on Saturdays in Nantes? »
ChatGPTError
Gemini1st
Perplexity1st
CopilotError
AI Overviews1st
AI Mode1st
« Which ergonomic chair for 8 hours a day? »Ahead of you : Brindille & Co
ChatGPTMissing
GeminiCited 3rd
PerplexityMissing
CopilotMissing
AI OverviewsMissing
AI ModeMissing
« An extendable table for 8 that doesn't wobble when opened? »
ChatGPT1st
GeminiCited 2nd
Perplexity1st
CopilotCited 2nd
AI Overviews1st
AI Mode1st
« Bunk beds or a loft bed for two kids aged 6 and 9? »Ahead of you : Maison Kerlan
ChatGPTMissing
GeminiMissing
PerplexityMissing
CopilotMissing
AI OverviewsCited 3rd
AI ModeMissing
« Machine-washable removable sofa covers: which ones last? »Ahead of you : Maison Kerlan
ChatGPTCited 2nd
GeminiCited 3rd
PerplexityCited 2nd
CopilotMissing
AI OverviewsCited 2nd
AI ModeCited 3rd
« Resin or aluminum garden furniture in the rain? »Ahead of you : Jardins d'Armor
ChatGPTMissing
GeminiCited 4th
PerplexityCited 3rd
CopilotMissing
AI OverviewsMissing
AI ModeCited 4th
« A leather sofa made in Europe, under €2,000? »
ChatGPTError
GeminiError
Perplexity1st
CopilotMissing
AI OverviewsError
AI Mode1st
« Solid oak table made in France: which brands? »Ahead of you : Atelier Duval
ChatGPTCited 3rd
GeminiCited 2nd
Perplexity1st
CopilotCited 3rd
AI OverviewsCited 2nd
AI ModeCited 2nd
« A convertible bed in French wood, with no toxic varnish? »Ahead of you : Brindille & Co
ChatGPTMissing
GeminiMissing
PerplexityCited 4th
CopilotMissing
AI OverviewsMissing
AI ModeMissing
« When is the best time to buy garden furniture? »
ChatGPTError
Gemini1st
Perplexity1st
CopilotMissing
AI Overviews1st
AI ModeError

The sources the AIs used for these answers

Decor magazine comparison38 citations · Doesn't cite you
Consumer media buying guide31 citations · Doesn't cite you
Competitor's page27 citations · Doesn't cite you
Parents' forum22 citations · Doesn't cite you
Online reseller product pages19 citations · Cites you
Your site17 citations · Cites you
Customer review site15 citations · Cites you
Interior designer's blog11 citations · Doesn't cite you
DIY video channel8 citations · Doesn't cite you

Example: twelve questions from a furniture retailer, across the six AIs. Competitor names are made up.

What Siggmund measures

For each answer, Siggmund records four families of information.

Your presence

Citation rate, position in the answer, first-choice recommendation, AI by AI and need by need.

The customer's reaction

The recreated customer reads the answer and says whether they would go to you or to a competitor. Being cited isn't enough, you have to make them want to.

The sources

The pages, media, comparison sites, forums, resellers and marketplaces the AI relies on to answer, and which cite your competitors.

Your reputation

The qualities AI attributes to you, your customers' concerns (health, environment, ethics, quality, service) and repeated errors about your prices or services.

What do AIs say about your brand?

See what AI says about me

The sources: where the AI looks for information

When an AI answers, it relies on pages: media, comparison sites, forums, resellers, marketplaces. If those pages cite your competitors and not you, the AI will do the same.

Siggmund records these sources, question by question. That is what then lets you act where the AI looks for information, and not only on your site.

A statistical model, not an average

AI answers vary from one time to the next. A raw average over a few answers can suggest progress or a drop that does not exist.

Siggmund consolidates the results with a Bayesian statistical model designed by the team's PhDs in mathematics, AI by AI. You see where you are gaining, where you are losing, to the benefit of which competitor, and why.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between being cited and being recommended?

Being cited means appearing in the answer. Being recommended means being the choice the AI advises. A brand can be cited often and rarely recommended.

What does “wrongly described” mean?

The AI gives false or outdated information about you: a price, a delivery area, a service you no longer offer. Siggmund compares it with what your site says.

What do you see in the first baseline?

What AIs say about your brand, the competitors ahead of you and your first actions, in your Siggmund workspace.

Are the results separated by AI?

Yes. Each AI has its own results, because they do not answer the same way.

What do AIs say about your brand?

Your address is all we need.

See what AI says about me